Vanilla
$
Island Fudge
$
Cotton Candy
$
Maine Blueberry
$
Chocolate Chip
$
Java Chunk
$
Cinnamon Bun
$
Strawberry
$
Coffee
$
Pistachio
$
Peach
$
S'mores
$
Moose Tracks
$
Banana
$
Butter Pecan
$
Cookie Monster
$
Cannoli
$
Cold Brew
$
Cookie Jar
$
Espresso Brownie
$
Rainbow Vanilla
$
Death By Chocolate
$
Black Cherry
$
Cookies + Cream
$
Cake+Ice Cream
$
Raspberry Choc Chip
$
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$
Mint Chocolate Chip
$
Peanut Butter Ripple
$
Chocolate Marshmallow
$
Salted Caramel Pretzel
$
Black Raspberry Blast
$
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
$
Coconut Almond Joy
$
Rainbow Sherbet
$
Raspberry Sorbet
$
Vegan Peanut Butter Fudge
$
Sugar Free Cherry Jubilee
$
Brownie Sundae
$
Professor Sundae
$
Chocolate Lovers
$
Cookie Dough Sundae
$
Create Your Own
$
Waffle Sandwich
$
Milk Shake
$
Snow Caps
$
Peanut Butter Cup
$
Pretzels
$
Hot Fudge
$
Reese Pieces
$
Marsh Mallow
$
Peanut Butter Sauce
$
Wet Walnuts
$
Pineapple
$
Heath Bar
$
Chocolate Jimmies
$
Mint Chip
$
Caramel Decadence
$
Rocky Road
$
Right when you walk past 31 John F Kennedy Blvd in Sea Isle City, it’s hard not to slow down a bit and peek at what’s going on inside this ice cream spot. The Yum Yums Ice Cream Menu feels like one of those playful boards that instantly pulls you in, whether you’re just craving a quick cone after the beach or planning a full-on dessert stop. There’s a nice mix of classic scoops and fun seasonal flavors, and honestly, it’s the kind of place where decision-making takes longer than expected in a good way. What stands out is how easy it feels to mix and match-simple soft serve one day, something a little more loaded the next. Plus, the vibe around the place makes the whole experience feel laid-back, like you’re meant to just hang around and enjoy it without rushing anywhere.